Why I march for Black Lives Matter

These words were shared as part of a panel with Dr. Buffie Longmire-Avital and Laurel Grauer, with Amy Rogers as moderator, on the topic of “Black Lives Matter from Jewish Perspectiveson August 5, 2020.

Questioning is part of human nature. Questioning is part of Jewish culture. During the 2016 Charlotte protests when I was out on the streets, there were Jews who questioned my engagement with the Black Lives Matter movement. They had read articles on the 2016 Movement for Black Lives Matter (BLM) political platform that included anti-Israel statements.

When shortly after, I attended the Charlotte Women’s March and heard a leader of Charlotte’s BLM movement speak, I quickly tracked her down after she stepped off the stage. I explained to her the issue I had with their platform and she, in turn, explained to me the issue she had with their platform. She went on to explain that Charlotte’s BLM group was not connected with the national organization. In the same way our Charlotte’s Women’s March was not part of the national Women’s March organization, so was our local BLM group separate.

As I marched on the streets in 2016, most people with whom I spent time had no close knowledge of or strong feelings surrounding Israel. The same holds true today.

I march and advocate for Black Lives Matter because I care about black lives, equality, and equity.

I march because I know what happens when one is victimized by white supremacy. My grandfather spoke out against Hitler in an underground newspaper in Nazi, Germany. I was named for my great aunt Judith Schindler who was murdered at the age of 32, alongside her husband and five kids. I understand that the same hate aimed at Blacks by White Nationalists is also aimed at Jews. Eric Ward in his book Skin in the Game speaks to this painful reality.

I march because I teach Holocaust and human rights. I know that the authors of the Nuremberg Laws were inspired by Jim Crow. They learned about legal disenfranchisement and discrimination from us.

There are those who say we shouldn’t march because of antisemitism but I say we should march because of antisemitism. Because of our past experiences with antisemitism, we know the devastation that unchecked hate can bring.

I march because Jews before me marched. I know that we can’t rest on the laurels of Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel who crossed the Edmund Pettus Bridge in Selma with Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Congressman John Lewis, all now of blessed memory. We can’t rest on the laurels of the memories of Andrew Goodman and Michael Schwerner, who were murdered in Mississippi along with James Chaney working to register votes during Freedom Summer. They were brave. They were martyred for the cause of social justice. But their acts were 55 years ago and most in the Black community have no idea about this history of collaboration. This movement will advance with or without us. We need to march today so that the next generation can see that we did our part when this chapter of America’s racial reckoning is written and be inspired to pursue justice, as well.

I march for my colleagues and friends who fear for their own safety and their children’s safety. I march for my fellow congregants and my fellow panelist, Dr. Longmire-Avital, whose anxiety rises when her kids simply walk their dog around the block on their own – fearing that they are at greater risk because of their darker color of their skin.

But most of all I march for myself. My neighbors pain prevents my own peace.

If you want to learn more about Black-Jewish relations consider taking our Jewish Studies at Queens University Fall Community Course entitled “Peaks and Valleys: Milestone Moments in Black-Jewish Relations.” To learn more click here.

[Image by Mike Von]

2 Comments Write a comment


  • Corine August 6, 2020

    Thank you for these powerful, meaningful, heartfelt words.

    • Rabbi Judith Schindler August 15, 2020

      I appreciate your presence and partnership in this work.

Leave a Reply